The Evolution of Performance Reviews: From Past to Present

Make feedback a winning habit on your team.
The annual review process, once hailed as a cornerstone of performance management, has fallen short in meeting the needs of modern organizations and their people. In this blog post, we'll review the history of performance reviews, examine the data behind their shortcomings, and explore actionable steps to make feedback, growth and performance work for you, your organization and your people.

Table of

Tracing the Origins of Performance Reviews

The roots of corporate performance reviews can be traced back to the early 20th century. There was a strong influence of the US military’s merit rating system. Initially designed to manage transfers and discharges of soldiers, this system gradually made its way into the corporate world. By the 1940s, annual performance appraisals had gained widespread popularity. And soon a majority of employers had adopted some form of review process.

Fast forward to the present day, and we find ourselves at a crossroads. While performance reviews have evolved over time, they have remained entrenched in outdated practices. These practices include forced ranking systems and a heavy focus on past performance. However, a growing emphasis on real-time employee development and growth is driving a movement towards ditching these antiquated processes in favor of more agile and effective feedback mechanisms.

Assessing the Impact of Traditional Reviews

The numbers behind traditional performance reviews paint a stark picture of their ineffectiveness:

These numbers underscore the urgent need for organizations to reassess their approach to performance management.

Navigating the Shift Towards Continuous Feedback

In response to the shortcomings, many organizations are embracing a shift towards continuous feedback. Leaders in the industry, including Jack Dorsey and prominent corporations like Deloitte and Accenture, are ditching annual reviews in favor of real-time feedback.

But implementing continuous feedback requires more than just a change in process. It requires a cultural shift. HR professionals play a pivotal role in championing this transformation. Their role includes helping their team through the change curve, and fostering an environment where feedback is valued, encouraged, and integrated into everyday practices.

Actionable Steps for Success

Whether your organization is looking to avoid, replace, or enhance its current review system, here are some actionable steps to consider:

  • Learn about the principles of continuous feedback and its benefits for organizational growth.
  • Post on LinkedIn to engage with peers and industry leaders to learn from their experiences and best practices.
  • Explore resources and tools, like Tandem, that facilitate real-time feedback exchange and performance tracking.
  • Collaborate with internal executive teams to align on performance goals, ensuring that feedback initiatives support broader business objectives.

Embracing the Future of Performance Management

The time has come to bid farewell to the outdated practices of traditional performance reviews and embrace a more agile approach. By prioritizing continuous feedback, organizations can empower their employees to reach their full potential, drive innovation, and achieve unparalleled growth.

At Tandem, we’re committed to partnering with HR and People teams to navigate this transformative journey. Tandem is designed to facilitate continuous feedback exchange, foster a culture of growth, and unleash the collective potential of your workforce. Together, let’s rewrite the narrative of performance management and create workplaces where feedback is not just a formality, but a catalyst for positive change.